William Estes, MD, is an orthopedic surgeon with Novant Health Orthopedic & Sports Medicine in Mount Pleasant who performs up to 200 rotator cuff repairs each year. In addition to rotator cuff expertise, Dr. Estes’ areas of focus include shoulder, knee and elbow injuries as well as shoulder and knee replacements.
When a patient presents with shoulder pain, recognizing the signs of a full-thickness rotator cuff tear and knowing when to refer can help maintain repairability and improve outcomes. In this Q&A, Dr. Estes shares the history and exam findings that warrant concern, when conservative care is appropriate, how referral timing affects repairability, what imaging may help and how advances in rotator cuff surgery are shaping treatment and recovery for your patients.
When a primary care physician, sports medicine clinician or advanced practice provider sees a patient with shoulder pain, what clinical findings should raise concern for a full-thickness rotator cuff tear?
Watch for markedly reduced strength, approximately 2/5 or 3/5 during the empty can test, which assesses the supraspinatus, or during resisted external rotation with the arm fully adducted at the patient's side. These weakness patterns are more concerning than pain alone, particularly when the deficit limits your patient's ability to actively raise, rotate or use the arm for routine activities.
Which findings on history and exam suggest a tear that warrants earlier orthopedic referral rather than an extended course of conservative care?
Many patients will hear or feel a pop or tear in their shoulder, followed shortly after by significant pain. Night pain is another key finding: pain that wakes patients from sleep and throbs and aches throughout the night.
What imaging is most useful before referral?
Imaging isn't required before referral. If the history and physical exam raise concern for a rotator cuff tear, you can refer your patient without obtaining imaging first. We routinely obtain X-rays during the patient visit and, based on the evaluation, may order an MRI or MRI arthrogram.
To refer your patients to Dr. William Estes or Novant Health Orthopedic & Sports Medicine in Mount Pleasant call 843-971-9350 or fax 843-971-9351
How much does timing matter once you suspect a full-thickness tear?
Making a definitive diagnosis is imperative because full-thickness tears can retract and become unrepairable if treatment is delayed. Once a tear retracts, it can be difficult and sometimes impossible to fix. The result is either a reverse shoulder replacement or the patient living with chronic pain.
At what point does a repairable tear become unrepairable, and how does that change the operative options you can offer your patient?
Full-thickness tears can become unrepairable around the four-month mark. After that, options shift to a reverse replacement or depending on the patient's age, a ligament transfer or a procedure called superior capsular reconstruction.
When is conservative management still the right call?
For most partial-thickness tears, we begin with conservative treatment. It's important to educate patients that tears over 50% thickness of the tendon are likely to progress to a full-thickness tear at some point. That said, we generally start conservatively with these tears.
How has rotator cuff surgery improved over the past decade?
Rotator cuff surgery has improved significantly in terms of postoperative pain. The addition of a preoperative nerve block by anesthesia to cover pain for the first 24 hours has been especially helpful. Performing the procedure arthoscopically also tends to decrease postoperative pain. Other advances include new anchor types, such as all-suture soft anchors versus metal anchors.
What should referring physicians know about how you approach rotator cuff surgery?
I recommend repairing most full-thickness tears, so they don't retract and become unrepairable. We tend to treat most partial-thickness tears conservatively, beginning with either a cortisone injection or physical therapy. Some patients also opt for a PRP injection and/or physical therapy for partial-thickness tears.
What final takeaways do you have about rotator cuff referrals, especially regarding what referring physicians can tell their patients?
It's often best for referring physicians to leave the choice of imaging to the orthopedic specialist. In some cases, MRIs aren't particularly helpful, for example, when a patient's condition is misdiagnosed as a rotator cuff tear when our exam indicates adhesive capsulitis. An MRI ordered before a patient's visit with us could end up being unnecessary if the actual diagnosis doesn't call for one.
Contributing subject matter expert:
National leaders in orthopedic surgery & quicker recovery times