Obesity is a life-threatening chronic disease. It’s generally not, as some still believe, the result of overeating and being sedentary.
That message is slowly trickling out to the public sphere. But there are still those who believe people with obesity should “just buckle down, exercise more and eat less,” said Dr. Neil McDevitt of Novant Health East Cooper Bariatric Surgery in Mount Pleasant, South Carolina.
In reality, it’s not that simple. Many with obesity suffer from a metabolic condition that prohibits them from achieving meaningful weight loss merely by changing their lifestyle, and have accompanying conditions, like painful arthritis, that make exercising difficult. For these individuals, bariatric surgery may be an option.
Personalized weight-loss programs to help you achieve a healthy lifestyle.
Bariatric surgery is an effective and sustainable treatment for obesity, medical studies show. Despite this, it remains underused, with only approximately 1% of all eligible patients nationwide undergoing the procedure. Bariatric surgery, like all weight-loss interventions, is neither quick nor easy. It requires an all-in commitment from the patient before surgery and (long) after. McDevitt tells people, “What we do is not for appearance; it’s for survival.”
We talked with McDevitt and three other bariatric surgeons – one from each of Novant Health’s regions – about what to expect before and after bariatric surgery.
What’s the biggest misconception about bariatric surgery?
That it’s the easy way out. There is, unfortunately, still a stigma about bariatric surgery we have yet to overcome.
Because GLP-1s (the class of drugs used to treat obesity and diabetes that are wildly popular now) are so effective, why should someone consider surgery? Isn’t a weekly injection easier?
Those drugs are very good tools in our arsenal, but the challenge is: We still aren’t sure about their long-term effects. And these are medications people may need to be on for a lifetime. They’re not an alternative to lifestyle modification.
I love pharmacotherapy as an alternative to surgery, however it must be used in conjunction with lifestyle changes. Bariatric surgery has a clear advantage over these medications, particularly in the treatment of type 2 diabetes: around 90% of diabetes goes into remission soon after surgery.
The surgery fundamentally alters hunger hormones and the way the body utilizes insulin and food.
Patients considering bariatric surgery generally need to lose 60, 100, 150 pounds. GLP-1s are designed for people who want to lose, maybe, up to 50 pounds. Surgery leads to faster and more sustainable results. And given the expense of the injectable medications – and the fact that people may need to be on them for a lifetime – surgery is generally the less expensive route over time.
How do you help ensure your patients’ success?
My patients taught me early on that the surgery we do is like changing tires. We have to fix the alignment at the same time – or they fail. And by that, I mean helping patients fundamentally change the way they think about food. They have to be able to sustain their weight loss.
We teach patients the difference between eating for nutrition and eating for other reasons such as boredom or stress. We see them monthly in preparation for surgery – for as long as they need us to. We won’t operate until they have a good handle on the dietary changes needed for long-term success.
They have to be motivated. The most motivated patients I see, typically, are those who’ve been told they have to lose weight before they can have a total knee or hip replacement. A highly motivated patient may be ready for surgery as soon as three months after their initial consult.
Not everyone is that eager. One patient was so reluctant that I worked with her for almost three years before her surgery.
My patients keep food journals and wear pedometers – and bring them both to their appointments. The numbers don't lie. If your goal is 5,000 steps a day, you’re either hitting that mark or you’re not. If you’re not, we’ll talk about why and find a way to increase that activity.
I remind patients that there’s no judgment in our office – ever. When I review a food journal, it’s not to judge but to get a window into their personal relationship with food.
What qualifications must be met to be a candidate for bariatric surgery?
Patients with a BMI of between 35 and 40 may be candidates if they suffer from weight-related medical conditions such as high blood pressure, diabetes or sleep apnea. (Click here for a BMI calculator.) Patients with a BMI of 40 or above may be candidates even without comorbidities. New criteria for surgery have been developed – but haven’t been adopted by insurance companies.
We now recognize that certain genetic factors make obesity more dangerous in some populations. Those of Asian descent with diabetes and a BMI of 27 or more are candidates for bariatric surgery.
Surgery is a long-term, effective way to lose weight and improve – or even eliminate – certain medical conditions. Even patients who are on dialysis for kidney failure are often recommended to have weight-loss surgery to qualify for a kidney transplant. For those patients, it’s the difference between being tied to a dialysis machine three times a week and regaining their independence.
Age, of course, is considered, but it’s just one of many factors reviewed when considering if surgery is appropriate.
What are some obstacles to receiving bariatric surgery?
The biggest reason we see for a patient’s reluctance to have surgery is lack of family support. Without that, lifestyle changes may be next-to-impossible. Most of my patients with obesity are so busy caring for everyone else’s needs that they neglect their health. I help them recognize their own value.
Our views on food are so deeply entrenched that when somebody changes the music, not everybody knows how to dance to it. It’s hard when one family member – especially if it’s the person responsible for preparing meals – wants to start eating differently.
While family support is important, there are other places patients can seek support, including through online support groups. There’s a large community of bariatric patients, and social media is a good place to find them.
Editor’s note: Sometimes, surgeons operate on family members – spouses, siblings – at the same time. Going through a major life change with a family member helps with accountability.
Is surgery right for everyone? If not, who’s it not right for?
Almost all patients who qualify for bariatric surgery would benefit from the health benefits it offers. However, patients must be ready to commit to the lifestyle changes that will ultimately help them achieve the best possible results.
All patients must undergo mandatory psychological testing to ensure that unmanaged psychiatric conditions would not prevent them from being successful after surgery. It’s mandatory that patients are not smoking, as this can lead to adverse events and outcomes from surgery. Patients must also be compliant with long-term, follow-up care; their care team should monitor their health and nutrition each year. Besides this, many patients – even with significant health conditions including heart and kidney failure – may still qualify and achieve significant benefits from surgery.