Key takeaways

  • Hernias do not heal on their own and often get larger, so even a hernia that isn’t causing symptoms may be worth discussing with a surgeon.
  • Some hernias can be monitored, but pain or difficulty doing normal activities may be signs that it’s time to discuss surgical treatment.
  • Recovery varies by the hernia and how it is repaired, but patients may need about four to six weeks after hernia surgery to get back to their usual energy level and activities.

About this episode

Hernias are common, but knowing when one needs treatment and what surgery might involve can raise a lot of questions. This episode of Meaningful Medicine with Novant Health explains common types of hernias, symptoms to watch for, when monitoring may be an option and what patients can expect from hernia repair and recovery. It also explores potential complications of untreated hernias and research into preventing hernias after abdominal surgery.

Dr. William Hope is a general surgeon at Novant Health General Surgery & Bariatrics in Wilmington. In the episode, he discusses the surgical and nonsurgical considerations he shares with patients and his approach to caring for the whole person.

Common questions about hernias

What is a hernia?

A hernia is a hole or weak area that can occur in the abdominal wall or inside the abdominal cavity. Common types include umbilical hernias near the belly button, inguinal hernias in the groin and incisional hernias that develop where someone previously had surgery.

Does every hernia require surgery?

No. Some hernias that aren't causing symptoms can be monitored, but William Hope, MD, explains that hernias do not heal themselves and usually become larger over time. He recommends discussing options with a surgeon, particularly if the hernia causes pain or interferes with activities.

What is a hiatal hernia?

A hiatal hernia occurs when there is an opening in the diaphragm, the muscle that separates the chest from the abdomen, allowing part of the stomach to move into the chest. It can cause acid reflux or difficulty swallowing, and treatment may include medication or, depending on the hernia, surgery.

What are the options for hernia repair?

Hernia repair can be performed using open, laparoscopic or robotic techniques, and mesh is often used in the repair. The appropriate approach depends on factors such as the type and size of the hernia, its location and how much it is bothering the patient.

How long does it take to recover from hernia surgery?

Recovery depends on the size of the hernia and how it is repaired. According to Dr. Hope, pain and discomfort often improve after a few days, but it can take about four to six weeks to recover and return to usual energy levels and activities. Postoperative activity recommendations are individualized to the patient and type of hernia.

What are the risks of leaving a hernia untreated?

Some inguinal or groin hernias can be monitored for a period of time, but complications are possible. A hernia can become incarcerated or strangulated, meaning intestine becomes trapped in the hernia, which can lead to bowel obstruction and potentially life-threatening problems. William Hope, MD says patients who are monitoring a hernia should understand the warning signs and when to contact their surgeon or go to the emergency room.

Episode chapters

00:00 Introductions
00:35 What is a hernia and what are the common types?
01:21 Deciding on surgery: when it's needed and monitoring symptoms
02:47 Understanding hiatal hernia and its symptoms
03:26 Overview of hernia treatment options
04:31 Recovery after hernia repair
05:11 Risks of not treating and watchful waiting
06:16 Trial to prevent incisional hernias with absorbable mesh
07:56 Reducing hernia risk for the general population
09:13 The surgeon's path and philosophy of care
10:54 Closing and episode wrap

Episode transcript

Melanie Cole, MS (Host): Welcome to Meaningful Medicine, a Novant Health podcast, bringing you access to leading doctors who answer questions they wish you would ask. From routine care to rare conditions, our physicians offer tips to navigate medical decisions and build a healthier future.

I'm Melanie Cole. And joining me to talk about hernias today is Dr. William Hope. He's a general surgeon affiliated with Novant Health General Surgery in Wilmington. Dr. Hope, thank you so much for joining us today. So, we're focusing on hernias. Can you describe what a hernia even is and explain some of the most common types that you see?

Dr. William Hope: Yeah, sure. Well, thanks for having me. I see a lot of hernias, and I think there's a lot of confusion about what a hernia actually is. And so, the easiest way that I explain this to my patients is a hernia is just a fancy doctor word for a hole. And you can get holes in your abdominal wall and even inside the abdominal cavity, and that can happen in a lot of different areas.

But the most common ones we see are what we call umbilical hernias, which are hernias at the belly button, or inguinal hernias, some people call them growing hernias, down in the patient's groin area.

Host: Well, thank you for explaining that. And how do you know if a hernia would benefit from surgical treatment? Should people monitor for pain and discomfort? What symptoms would we even know to see. Because sometimes, you know, with people that have an umbilical, you can sort of see it, especially if they're doing like a sit-up or lying flat. So, what are we looking for, Dr. Hope? And are we looking for symptoms that would make this something uncomfortable or do they really need to be checked?

Dr. William Hope: Yeah. Well, I would say most hernias probably at least need a visit to your surgeon. And if you have a hernia, which often most patients will come in to see us because they have a bulge. They feel a bulge either at their belly button, in their groin area, or in a place they've had previous surgery, which is another common hernia that we see.

Sometimes these hernias are asymptomatic, especially at the belly button area. And they really don't bother patients. And in those cases, sometimes we can monitor these hernias. The one downside about monitoring hernias, however, is that hernias will never heal themselves. And over time, they usually get bigger.

And a lot of times when they get bigger, they start to cause symptoms to patients. So, if you are having symptoms related to your hernia pain or not being able to do some of the activities that you want to do, then I really recommend seeing a surgeon to discuss surgical treatment options. And even if they're asymptomatic to you, I do think it's worthwhile at least seeing a surgeon and seeing what your options are.

Host: And I would like to discuss the options. Before I do, people have heard the term hiatal hernia. Tell us what that is.

Dr. William Hope: Yeah. Hiatal hernias are often confused with hernias because it is a hernia, a type of hernia. But this one is where there's a hole in your diaphragm muscle which separates your chest from your abdominal wall. And a lot of times in hiatal hernias, part of your stomach can go up into your chest and can cause symptoms such as reflux, acid reflux, or even trouble swallowing. And those often can be treated with medicines. But a lot of times, depending on how big those hernias are and how much stomach is in your chest, we often have some surgical options for that as well.

Host: So, we'll stick with the type that we discussed earlier. Tell us a little bit about some of the treatment options that are available.

Dr. William Hope: Yeah. So, surgery obviously is one of the major treatment options for hernias, if they're symptomatic. While we can watch some of these, most patients that are good candidates for surgery, we recommend some type of surgery, and it depends a lot on the type of hernia, how big it is, where it is, and how bad it's bothering patients, because a lot of these can be done electively at the patient's, you know, convenience.

And we have multiple options for how to fix these hernias. Often hernias require the use of mesh, which I know a lot of patients have questions and concerns about, but it is by far the best way to fix most of these hernias and is a very safe way to fix it. We also have robotic techniques, laparoscopic techniques, and open techniques to fix many of these hernias. And there's pluses and minuses of each of those techniques.

Host: With so many options available, Dr. Hope, what is recovery like when you fix someone's hernia, whether you're using mesh and minimally invasive or robotics? What is recovery like?

Dr. William Hope: Yeah. Recovery actually can be a real thing with these hernias. And again, it depends a little bit on the size of the hernia and how they're repaired. But I tell all my patients that even though most of the time after a few days patient's pain and discomfort is better, it really takes about four to six weeks to recover from these surgeries.

And we often get a lot of questions from patients about what activities they can and can't do after surgery. And usually, that's individualized to the patient and the type of hernia. But I usually tell patients it's going to be a good month or six weeks before they're back to 100% as far as their energy level and doing all the activities that they want to do.

Host: Are there risks for not treating a hernia? Is this something that can be watchful waiting or is it really something that needs a surgical intervention much of the time?

Dr. William Hope: Yeah. We do have some information about watchful waiting, especially for the inguinal hernias or groin hernias. And we do know that there's some safety in watching these hernias for a period of time. One of the major concerns, however, is these hernias can what we call incarcerate or strangulate, where intestine can go out of that hole or that hernia and get caught and can cause bowel obstructions and can cause some major life-threatening issues.

So in patients that I'm undergoing monitoring or watchful waiting with, I really have to talk to them a lot about looking out for these signs of incarceration or strangulation so that they're aware of that, if they start to feel those symptoms, that they call me or go to the emergency room so that they can get these taken care of quickly.

Host: Dr. Hope, you're giving us so much to think about and so much great information. Since hernias, as you said at the beginning, can develop at the site of a previous surgery, tell us a little bit about the clinical trial that you participated in to evaluate a potential tool for prevention.

Dr. William Hope: Yeah. Well, this is a really exciting trial, and we're lucky at Novant and our team here to be a part of this. This is a trial looking at the use of a mesh at the time of the initial surgery to try to prevent hernias. And so, for most of our surgeries we do, and these are open surgeries that still are very common, although laparoscopic and robotic surgery is becoming more common, we still have to do a lot of surgery where we make a big incision through the mid portion of your abdomen.

And in those cases at the end, we have to sew your tissue back together. And the hernia rates related to that can range from anywhere from 10% to almost 50% of patients. So, a lot of those patients that have had these laparotomy type incisions will go on to develop hernias. And so, this trial is looking at a potential better way while at the initial time of surgery, instead of just suturing the tissue back together, we suture the tissue back together and then use an absorbable mesh to help give that strength to see if we can reduce the rate of incisional hernias.

And we just finished enrolling patients for that trial, and we're going to follow those patients for the next five years to see if this new way to do it will make an impact on incisional hernias. And if so, I think it will be a really big game-changer for us as surgeons and patients to try to really reduce the rate of incisional hernias in these cases.

Host: That's fascinating. It's really an exciting time in your field, and I hope you'll join us and update us as that comes through. So, are there ways for the general population to reduce their risk of hernia? We've heard people say, "Oh, if you lift that too-heavy thing, you know, you're going to get a hernia." Is that a myth? Is that true? How can we reduce our risk?

Dr. William Hope: Yeah. Unfortunately, there's not a ton of things you can do to reduce the risk. Some of these are genetic in nature and wear and tear in areas of our body, that just become weak over time. Now, clearly, I do talk to some of my patients, and I see many that have come in after lifting something heavy and have developed a hernia.

So, I think you need to at least be cautious when you're doing, major lifting, especially as you get older, especially if you don't have to do that. But sometimes you can develop these hernias without lifting or without strenuous activity. So, they are common problems. I will say, you know, also talk to your surgeon when you're undergoing a surgery to see if some of your surgeries could be done in what we call a minimally invasive manner.

We know the smaller the incisions we make on people's abdominal wall, the less likely they are to develop hernias. And just be aware of these. I mean, I think they're so common that one in four men in their lifetimes will develop an inguinal hernia. So, it is such a common problem. But thankfully, there's good solutions to fix them that are pretty well-tolerated.

Host: Dr. Hope, before we wrap up, I'd like to ask you how general surgery became a passion of yours. What drew you to this specialty? And give us your philosophy of care. Tell us about treating that whole person and what drew you to general surgery.

Dr. William Hope: Yeah. Great question. I'm afraid I got this honestly. My father was a general surgeon, and I think just growing up in that household and watching him work and take care of patients. And really, surgery being sort of the main focus of his life to try to help others, I think was instilled in me at a very young age.

And I really like that philosophy. I think general surgery, we have a unique opportunity to really impact patients' lives by doing a surgery, sometimes a life-saving surgery. A lot of times in hernia, we're improving patients' quality of life. So, it's very rewarding career. As you mentioned, I try to treat the whole person.

I think, you know, surgery, we have a very short time to impact a patient's care, and often, you know, we'll see the patient, operate on them, see them in our postoperative care for a few weeks, and then may not see them for a while. So, I really try to get to know my patients and make sure that, you know, I'm treating their surgical disease process, but also making sure that we have good impacts on their lives and healthy living styles and conditions. And so, it's a very rewarding thing.

Host: Thank you so much, Dr. Hope, for joining us today and sharing your expertise. Thank you again. And to find a physician, you can visit novanthealth.org. For more health and wellness information from our experts, you can always visit healthyheadlines.org. I'm Melanie Cole. And that concludes this episode of Meaningful Medicine, a podcast from the specialists at Novant Health.